The Mexi Plate

Homemade Corn Tortillas (Soft, Not Cracked)

Elena Valdés

Elena Valdés

Elena Valdés is a Mexican-American home cook and the culinary heart behind MexiPlate. Inspired by the bustling kitchens of her childhood in Jalisco and Texas, she specializes in translating authentic Mexican flavors into approachable recipes for everyday cooks. Whether she is sharing her grandmother's secret for the perfect tamale masa or a quick 30-minute weeknight enchilada bake, Elena believes that good food is the best way to bring people together.

Published November 13, 2026

When I was little, the sound I remember most from my abuela’s kitchen was not a timer. It was masa being patted and pressed, then that first soft puff on the comal. Corn tortillas are humble, everyday food, but when they are made right they are also the best kind of magic: warm, flexible, and strong enough to scoop beans without tearing.

This is my go-to method for soft table tortillas using only masa harina, warm water, and salt. No lard, no flour, no guessing. Just the right dough feel, a steady comal, and a few small tricks that keep tortillas tender instead of cracked or stiff.

A pair of hands opening a tortilla press to reveal a freshly pressed round of corn tortilla dough between two pieces of plastic

What you need

Ingredients

  • 2 cups masa harina (nixtamalized instant corn masa flour, like Maseca or Minsa)
  • 1 1/2 cups warm water, plus a little extra as needed (depending on brand, you may land closer to 1 1/3 to 1 2/3 cups total)
  • 1/2 teaspoon fine salt (or 3/4 teaspoon kosher salt)

Tools that help

  • Tortilla press (cast iron is my favorite, but any sturdy press works)
  • Plastic liner for pressing (a cut-open zip-top bag or two pieces of produce-bag plastic)
  • Comal, cast iron skillet, or flat griddle
  • Clean kitchen towel or tortilla warmer

Why warm water? Warm water hydrates masa harina faster and more evenly, so your dough presses cleanly and the edges do not crumble. More than the measuring cup, trust the dough feel.

Step-by-step tortillas

1) Mix the dry ingredients

In a medium bowl, whisk together the masa harina and salt. This keeps the salt from clumping in one spot.

2) Add warm water and hydrate

Pour in 1 1/2 cups warm water and mix with your hand until a shaggy dough forms. Then knead in the bowl for about 1 minute until it looks uniform.

The dough feel you want: It should feel like soft Play-Doh. When you pinch it, it holds together smoothly. It should not feel sandy, dry, or crack at the edges.

  • If it feels dry or crumbly, add warm water 1 teaspoon at a time.
  • If it feels sticky and coats your fingers, sprinkle in masa harina 1 teaspoon at a time.

3) Rest the dough

Cover the bowl with a damp towel or lid and let it rest for 10 to 15 minutes. This gives the masa time to fully absorb water, which is one of the biggest secrets to tortillas that do not crack.

A close-up of a smooth ball of masa dough in a bowl with a damp kitchen towel nearby, ready to be portioned

Portion and press

1) Preheat the comal

Set your comal or skillet over medium-high heat and let it heat for several minutes while you portion the dough. You want a confident sizzle when the tortilla hits the pan, not a slow fade.

No oil needed. A dry comal gives you the best texture for everyday table tortillas.

2) Portion evenly

This makes 12 tortillas, about 6 inches each. Portion the dough into 12 balls, roughly 35 to 45 grams each, depending on how thick you like them. Keep the dough balls covered with a damp towel as you work.

3) Press with plastic

Line the tortilla press with plastic. Place a dough ball slightly off-center, a little toward the hinge helps it press evenly. Press firmly.

Pressing test: Peel back the plastic. The tortilla should lift off cleanly, with smooth edges and no cracking. If the edges look jagged or split, the dough needs a touch more water and another quick knead.

A cast iron tortilla press on a kitchen counter with plastic liner inside, ready for pressing masa

Cook on the comal

Cooking is where softness is won or lost. You are drying the surface just enough to set the tortilla, without drying the whole thing out. Use the times as a guide, but follow the visual cues, since pan thickness and burners vary.

The three-stage cook

  1. First side: Lay the tortilla on the hot comal. Cook about 30 to 40 seconds, until the color dulls and the edges look slightly dry.
  2. Second side: Flip and cook about 40 to 60 seconds, until you see light brown spots forming and the tortilla looks more set.
  3. Final set: Flip again and cook 10 to 20 seconds. If your heat is right, you might see a small puff. Do not chase a huge balloon. A gentle puff is enough.

As each tortilla finishes, slide it into a towel-lined basket or wrap it in a clean kitchen towel. That trapped heat keeps tortillas flexible while you cook the rest.

A freshly pressed corn tortilla cooking on a hot comal with light brown spots beginning to form

Keep them soft

If tortillas stiffen on the plate, it is almost always one of these issues:

  • They cooled uncovered. Tortillas need to rest stacked and wrapped so they steam each other.
  • The comal was too cool. A lukewarm pan dries the tortilla slowly, which makes it tough.
  • They cooked too long. Overcooking is dehydration, especially on the last flip.
  • Dough was a little dry. Dry dough makes dry tortillas. Add water by teaspoons and knead again.

My everyday habit: I keep a towel on the counter, and every tortilla goes right in, stacked, then wrapped. Even five uncovered minutes can change the texture.

Troubleshooting

Problem: Edges crack when pressing

  • Cause: Dough is too dry or not fully hydrated.
  • Fix: Knead in warm water 1 teaspoon at a time, then rest 5 more minutes. Press again.

Problem: Tortillas crack when folding

  • Cause: Tortillas cooled uncovered or were overcooked.
  • Fix: Keep them wrapped. Next round, shave off 10 to 15 seconds total cook time.
  • Quick rescue: Reheat on the comal 10 seconds per side, then wrap in a towel for 2 minutes.

Problem: Dough sticks to the plastic

  • Cause: Dough is too wet, or your plastic has wrinkles that grab the masa.
  • Fix: Sprinkle in a little masa harina, knead, and try again. Also smooth the plastic liner tight in the press.

Problem: Tortillas feel gummy or raw inside

  • Cause: Tortillas are too thick, undercooked, or the heat is too high and they brown before they cook through.
  • Fix: Lower heat slightly and cook the second side a bit longer. Press a touch thinner next time. If your dough felt very wet, add a pinch more masa and rest it again.

Problem: Tortillas are dry and stiff

  • Cause: Dough was too dry, comal too cool, or cook time too long.
  • Fix: Add more water to the dough, preheat the comal longer, and shorten the cook. Stack and wrap.

Problem: Tortillas do not puff

  • Cause: Usually a heat issue, tortillas are too thick, or the tortilla did not seal well on the first side.
  • Fix: Make sure the comal is fully hot and press a little thinner. Puffing is nice, but not required for soft table tortillas.

Small upgrades

  • Salt: If you like a tortilla that tastes seasoned on its own, increase to 3/4 teaspoon fine salt.
  • Water range: Different brands, grinds, and humidity change absorption. Start with the recipe amount, then adjust by teaspoons until the dough feels soft and smooth.
  • Blue masa harina: It behaves similarly, but it sometimes drinks a little more water. Again, trust the dough feel.
  • No tortilla press? Use a heavy skillet. Place the dough ball between plastic, press down firmly, then rotate and press again until evenly thin.

What I do not recommend for everyday table tortillas: adding oil to the dough. It can make pressing easier, but it can also mute the clean corn flavor and change the bite. If your tortillas are cracking, it is almost always hydration, not fat.

Store and reheat

Same day

Keep tortillas wrapped in a towel at room temperature for a few hours. If you are serving later, let them cool, then transfer to a sealed bag.

Refrigerator

They are best within 3 days. Reheat on a dry comal over medium heat for 10 to 20 seconds per side, then stack and wrap for a minute so they relax.

Freezer

For best quality, freeze up to 2 months, with parchment between tortillas in a freezer bag. Reheat straight from frozen on a comal, flipping until flexible, then wrap to steam.

Quick checklist

  • Warm water, then rest the dough 10 to 15 minutes.
  • Dough should feel soft and smooth, not sandy.
  • Press between plastic, no extra flour needed.
  • Comal fully preheated, listen for a confident sizzle.
  • Cook in three stages and do not overcook.
  • Stack tortillas and keep them wrapped.

If you try this method, make a double batch when you have the time. Fresh tortillas turn into the best chilaquiles, tortilla soup, and enchiladas, but honestly, my favorite is still the simplest: one warm tortilla, a pinch of salt, and a little bite right off the stack.